The Faculty History Project documents faculty members who have been associated with the University of Michigan since 1837. Key in this effort is to celebrate the intellectual life of the University. This Faculty History Website is intended as a component of the effort to document the extraordinary academic achievements of Michigan’s faculty in building and sustaining one of the world’s great universities. It provides access to a comprehensive database of information concerning the thousands of faculty members who have served the University of Michigan.
Find out more.
The Bentley Historical Library serves as the official archives for the University.
President Angell's Reminiscences
The Michigan Alumnus 131-139
PRESIDENT ANGELL'S REMINISCENCES
Few books could be of more inter est to Michigan graduates, especially to those who remember the University of past years, than Dr. Angell's recent ly published "Reminiscences." In this little volume, Michigan's loved Presi dent Emeritus has not attempted an exhaustive or critical memoir of his long and active years in the University and in public affairs. Rather, he has sat down in his easy chair, and with char acteristic simplicity and grace, given certain memories of interesting phases of his varied career, just as those who know him best have been accustomed to hear him talk, in intimate conversa tion, of his past life, drawing for illus tration upon his vast fund of accumu lated experiences.
Everyone who has known Dr. Angell either as student or as associate, will find many things of great interest in this work, though almost of neces sity in such a general work he has subordinated his connection with the Uni versity to the wider range of his activi ties in public life. Nevertheless, one is able to trace the development of the man and of his personality and to presage the scholar of later years in the earlier pictures of the New England schoolboy, and of the student in Europe almost sixty years ago, pre paring for his first professorship. Particularly interesting are the per sonal anecdotes of commanding char acters in public life with whom Dr. Angell has been thrown in contact and the "inside history" of many political questions with which he has been con cerned.
The history of his early life, which he gives in his first chapter, is of per haps particular interest to Michigan readers. After chronicling his birth January 7, 1829, and giving some ac count of his family, he says:
"My immediate ancestors, like many of the farmers of former days who lived on some important thoroughfare combined the business of tavern-keep ing with that of farming. At an early day the Providence and Norwich Turnpike Company, whose road pas sed through our farm, was chartered. The farmers of several towns in east ern Connecticut then marketed their products in Providence, and so travel led the turnpike road. During the War of 1812, much of the travel and transportation by land between Bos ton and New York went by this route. Good inns were therefore needed. Through the period of my boyhood the number of travellers who sought ac commodations in the spacious house , which my grandfather erected in 1810, was very considerable. In earlier days, the town meetings were held at the tavern. In my own time, the mili tary gatherings—the 'General Train ings"—were held in the intervals near by; political meetings, occasionally a justice's court, were held in a large hall which formed a part of the house. Compared with the seclusion of the ordinary farmer's boy's life, it will readily be seen that life here was very stirring. I have always felt that the knowledge of men I gained by the ob servations and experiences of my boy hood in the country tavern has been of the greatest service. Human nature could be studied in every variety, from that of the common farm laborer to travellers of the highest breeding and refinement. The eminent political speakers were always entertained a t our table, and some of them were very helpful friends in my later life. If, as I have sometimes been assured, I have any power of adaptation to the society of different classes of men, I owe it in no small degree to these varied associations of my boyhood. (This and all the following excerpts from the 'book are copyright by Longmans, Green & Co., and published by special permission of the publishers. THE ALUMNUS desires to acknowledge their kindness in giving this permission. —EDITOR. )
*********
"At a very early age (I know not how early), I was sent to the District School. I remember that I was so young that my father used frequently to take me to school on horseback in front of him on the saddle. A large boy of the neighborhood was hired to take charge of me on the road when I walked. The district school was then in a very primitive state. A sloping board attached to the wall quite around the room was the writing desk for all the larger pupils. They sat on benches with their backs towards the middle of the room. The small scholars sat on low benches in the centre of the room. Those who wrote made their own writing books. They purchased unruled paper, cut it into leaves, stitch ed them together, put a rough brown paper cover on, and ruled the lines with a leaden plummet. The first duty in the morning was to mend the goose quill pens, and in the winter to thaw the ink on the stove. The highest branch was Daboll's Arithmetic, and the older pupils who had completed it one winter came back the next and ciphered through it again. Reading, spelling, writing, a little grammar, elementary geography, and arithmetic, furnished the whole curriculum.
*********
"While during my fourteenth year I was at school at the Academy, Mr. O. S. Fowler, a somewhat noted phre nologist of that day, gave some lectures in the village of North Scituate and made a professional 'examination' of my head. I still have his written report on me. It was ridiculous in its exaggerated estimate of my gifts, but it had one good result. He persuaded my relatives and friends that by study I was overtaxing my strength, and that I ought to leave school for a rime and lead a vigorous out-of-door life. While I was by no means ill, I have little doubt that I owe in some degree the physical vigour with which I have been blessed all my life to the fact that owing to his counsel I spent the next two seasons, from early spring till late autumn, at work upon my father's farm, side by side with his hired men, hoeing my row and mowing my swath and learning all the details of farm work. Much of this I had previously learned in vacations; but I now learned thoroughly how much backache a dol lar earned in the fields represented. I was also enabled to see how the world looks from the point of view of the laboring man. Often in later years, when weary with study, I was inspired with new zeal by recalling how much severer were the fatigue and monotony of the work of the farmer's boy. It is a good fortune for a boy to have known by experience what hard and continuous manual labor means."
Interesting is his account of his boy- hood life in the rural Rhode Island town, where the practice of the great est economy was necessary to make a small farm support a family. He says that in 1840 the census taker permit ted him to accompany him in his gig over the larger part of the town. As an evidence of the simplicity of those times, they entered only two or three houses which had any other carpets or rugs than those which the occupants had made from rags, and there were not more than two pianos in the town. Although Scituate was only twelve miles from Brown University; he was the first boy from there to graduate from college. Of his college educa tion he says:
"Up to the time I left the Academy I had no fixed plan for life. My teach ers had encouraged me to believe that I could succeed in college studies. But, although at the age of fourteen I had covered more ground, especially in Latin and mathematics, than was required for admission to any of the New England colleges, I had no defi nite purpose of going to college. Dur ing the summers I was at home on the farm. I made some unsuccessful ef forts to secure a clerkship in business establishments in Providence; but in my fifteenth year it was clear that I ought to decide what career I should endeavor to follow. My father in formed me that he was able and willing to send me to college, but in that case would hardly be able, in justice to my five brothers and sisters, to aid me further. It was left to me to say whether I should go. I was certain that it would gratify both him and my mother if I chose to take the college life, and so the die was cast.
"Conscious that in my somewhat prolonged absence from school to knowledge of the classics had become rather rusty, and being still a year be low the age set for entering Brown University, I spent the larger part of a school year in the University Grammar School in Providence. It was then conducted by Mr. Merrick Lyon and Mr. Henry S. Frieze; afterwards the distinguished Professor of Latin in the University of Michigan. My studies were mainly in the classes of the latter. Contact with this inspiring teacher formed an epoch in my intel lectual life, as in that of so many other boys. He represented the best type of the modern teacher, at once critical as a grammarian and stimulating with the finest appreciation of whatever was choicest in the classic masterpieces. At first, as we were showered with questions such as I had never heard before, it seemed to me, although the reading of the Latin was mainly a re- view to me, that I should never emerge from my state of ignorance. But there was such a glow of enthusiasm in the instructor and in the class, there was such a delight in the tension in which we were kept by the daily exercises, that no task seemed too great to be en countered. Though in conjunction with our reading we devoured the Latin grammar so that by the end of the year we could repeat almost the whole of it, paradigms, rules, and ex ceptions without prompting, the work of mastering it did not seem dry and onerous, for we now felt how the in creasing accuracy of our knowledge of the structure of the language en hanced our enjoyment of the Virgil and the Cicero, whose subtle and less obvious charms we were aided by our teacher to appreciate.
*********
"My college life covered the period from 1845 to 1849. In these days, when the faculty numbers nearly a hundred, it is difficult to comprehend how a faculty of seven men carried on the institution with vigour and success. I need hardly say that each one of the seven was a man of force and was ad mirably qualified for his special work.
"Professor Boise, who afterwards at the University of Michigan and the Chicago Theological Seminary won so high a reputation, had charge of the Greek. He manifested the same phil ological acumen which always distin guished him. But he seemed to us at that time to dwell too much on the minutiae of grammar, and not enough on the beauties of Greek literature. The current saying among us was that 'he would die for an enclitic.' But it is impossible to overstate the influence , which he and his colleague, Profes sor Frieze, exerted in the West through their labors at the University of Michi gan in diffusing love for the study of the ancient classics.
Almost equally interesting are Dr. Angell's memories of his Southern, journey, —the record of seven months spent on horseback, touring the South with a classmate, Rowland Hazard. His memories of this trip give a very vivid and interesting picture of the South some ten years before the war. The succeeding chapters deal with his work in civil engineering in which he became so interested that when the professorship in Brown University was first offered him, it was a question whether he would return to a professorship in civil engineering or in mod ern languages. He finally chose the latter, and after a year and a half study in Europe, he returned to Brown at the age of twenty-four as the youngest member of the faculty. His profes sorship in Brown and editorship of the Providence Journal are the subject of the fourth chapter, while the next deals with his succeeding Presidency of the University of Vermont. Dr. Angell's diplomatic career is covered by chapters six, seven, eight and nine. His accounts of the mission to China; the Canadian Fisheries Commission and the Deep Waterways Commission; his summer trips to Europe; and the mission to the Ottoman Empire, are all filled with shrewd and pertinent comments upon men and affairs and illuminated by vivid anecdotes drawn from personal experience. The final chapter is devoted to his work as President of the University of Michi gan. In regard to his work at Ann Arbor, he says:
"In 1869, to my surprise I was in vited to visit the University of Michigan and decide whether I would ac cept the presidency of the institution which Dr. Haven had resigned. My wife accompanied me, and we spent two or three days at Ann Arbor. We were much impressed with the vigour and the promise of the University. But on returning to Burlington, I found that the men who had rallied generously to the support of the col lege would be sorely disappointed if I left them then. I decided that it was my duty to decline the invitation to Michigan. So I devoted myself with all my energy to the continuance of my work in Vermont. In 1871, the invitation to Michigan was renewed with much earnestness. I felt that I had discharged my duty to my Ver mont friends and that the college could move on fairly without me. I had some hesitation about undertak ing so large a responsibility as that at Michigan. One day when I men tioned this to a friend who had very large business interests, he said, 'I have found if you have a long lever it is as easy to raise a large load as to lift a small weight with a short lever.'
"After careful consideration I de cided to accept the invitation to Michi gan. In compliance with the request of the Regents of the University, I attended the Commencement at Ann Arbor on June 28, 1871, and delivered my In augural. I then returned to Burling- ton and finished the academic year , which terminated on August 3. I re- moved to Ann Arbor with my family early in September."
His personal memories of his col leagues upon that early Faculty will be particularly interesting:
"Dr. Henry S. Frieze, Professor of Latin for the two years prior to my coming Acting President, was a man of rare qualities, a passionate lover of art and of music, a scholar of large and varied attainments and of the finest literary taste, an inspiring teacher and a most winsome spirit. His influence on students and on his colleagues, in fostering the love of classical learning and in the diffusion of high and broad university ideals through all the West, causes his memory to be cherished with peculiar respect and affection.
"Rev. Dr. Benjamin F. Cocker, Pro fessor of Philosophy, had had a ro mantic life. A Methodist circuit preacher in Yorkshire in early life, he lived for years among the miners in Australia. On his voyage from that country he was wrecked on an island in the Pacific, inhabited partly by savages. After a narrow escape with his family he arrived in this State in utter destitution. Assigned to the care of a small country church, his talent soon made him known and secured his call to important churches, and finally to the chair in the Univer sity. His opportunities for gaining an education had been slender, but by his marked ability and his great industry he had overcome in large degree the limitations of his earlier years, though he never ceased to lament them. Both as a preacher and a teacher he had a singular charm of voice and manner which, added to his clearness and sim plicity in discussions of the problems of philosophy, made his instructions a delight to his pupils. He is remember ed by them with abiding affection and gratitude.
"Edward Olney, Professor of Mathematics, also had a unique history. He was never in school but a few weeks. Of mathematics he seemed to have from childhood an intuitive com prehension. His geometry he learned while following the plough. He drew the figures with chalk on the plough beam and mastered the demonstrations while travelling in the furrow. Though probably his attainments did not at last reach much beyond the range of the higher instruction in the under graduate course, he had a most unusual gift as a teacher. He not only made his instruction simple and clear, but what is not common in colleges, he made the study of mathematics a fav orite study of the great body of students. He had a manly frankness and honesty of character which often gave to his expressions the air of bluntness, but commanded the highest respect of his pupils and cultivated in them a spirit of manliness and honesty kindred to his own. He was a man of most earnest religious nature and was a power for righteousness both in college and in the community.
"Charles Kendall Adams was Pro fessor of History. He had acquired his enthusiasm for historical study un der Andrew D. White, when he filled the Chair of History in this Univer sity. Mr. Adams had recently return ed from study in Germany where he had become familiar with the Seminar method, in introducing which he after wards was the pioneer in American universities. Mr. Adams was even then greatly interested in university problems and was carefully studying all experiments in university adminis tration, both in America and Europe. He subsequently made good use of his knowledge of universities as Presi dent of Cornell University and of the University of Wisconsin.
"Moses Coit Tyler was Professor of Rhetoric and English Literature. He was already master of that attractive style which lent such a charm to every thing that he wrote and inspired his classes with a love for the best in liter ature and for purity and vivacity in their essays and speeches. In his private study he was already showing that deep interest in American History and the early American authors, which gave shape and color to his later works. He had a fine sense of humor, which enlivened his instruction and made him a most agreeable companion.
"Alexander Winchell, like Profes sors of Science in most American col leges at that time, was giving elemen tary instruction in Geology, Zoology, and Botany, but by his powerful imagination and brilliant eloquence was widely known as one of the most successful popular lecturers on science. He was afterwards President of the Syracuse University.
"James C. Watson, Professor of Astronomy, was a man whose mathe matical intuitions were near to genius. The son of an Irish carpenter, he was one of the finest products of the Michi gan System of Public Education, for he received his entire training in the public schools of Ann Arbor and in the University. While he was yet a student he made a telescope and with it discovered a comet. While still a young man he discovered asteroids and wrote a textbook on Astronomy, which gave him an enviable reputa tion among astronomers here and in Europe. His college teachers said that as a student he was almost as apt in languages as in mathematics, and if he had cultivated them as a profes sion, might have won distinction in that field. He had unlimited capacity for work. It seemed as though he could observe all night and then study all day. In teaching he had none of the methods of the drillmaster. But his lecture or his talk was so stimulating that one could not but learn and love to learn by listening. I have heard his pupils say that sometimes while discus sing an intricate problem he would have an entirely new demonstration sud denly flash upon his mind as by in spiration and then and there he would write it out upon the blackboard.
"George S. Morris, a man of the widest reading, was the Professor of Modern Languages. He had already translated Ueberweg's History of Philosophy. He afterwards welcomed the opportunity to give his whole time to teaching philosophy here and in the Johns Hopkins University, leaving in both institutions a profound impression upon his classes.
"Edward L. Walter was then giv ing instruction in Latin. Later he had charge of the work in German and in the Romance Languages. He was a master alike of ancient and modern literatures. Gifted with remarkable powers of acquisition, he was one of the most successful of teachers. We were robbed of him while in the prime of his strength by the sinking of the steamship Bourgogne.
"M. L. D'Ooge, Professor of Greek, was absent in Europe, but the depart ment was in the hands of Elisha Jones and Albert H. Pattengill, than whom better class room teachers of the clas sics were to be found in no American college.
*********
"In the Law Department were the three great teachers, who had guided its fortunes from its foundation, Thomas M. Cooley, James V. Camp bell, and Charles I. Walker. Never was a law school so fortunate as this was in beginning its work and con tinuing it for so many years under such gifted instructors. Charles A. Kent, a worthy coadjutor, had recently joined them. It was not strange that the school attracted students from all parts of the land.
"Professors Cooley and Campbell were on the Supreme Bench of the State. The Court, by the wisdom of its decisions, had already won the highest respect of the legal profession throughout the country. Judge Cooley had also won renown by his great work on Constitutional Limitations. He seemed to have an intuitive perception of legal relations. He was a man of indefatigable industry. Beyond all men I have known, he possessed the power of writing rapidly and with such accuracy that no reader could misunderstand his meaning.
"Judge Campbell was a scholarly man of wide reading, and of a grace ful style in writing or speaking. He was most familiar with the early his tory of the State and especially with the customs and traditions of the French population of Detroit and the vicinity. His narrations of the de tails of their life were as fascinating as those of the best French raconteurs. His lectures on law were dif fuse, but so charming in manner, like his conversation, that they held the undivided attention of his students.
"Professor Walker was so lucid and methodical in his instruction that his classes always testified to the great benefit they received from him.
*********
"I was also soon struck with the good results of the plan adopted the year before my arrival of bringing the High Schools into closer relations with the University, by receiving on diploma the. graduates of schools which had been approved by the Literary Faculty after inspection of them. This innovation on the practice of Ameri can colleges was due to the fertile mind of Dr. Frieze, who took the idea from the usage of the German Universities in receiving the graduates of the Gym nasia without examination of the stu dents. In adapting the plan to our needs, the Faculty wisely made provision for a visit to the schools by some University Professors. I made many of these visits. The advantages both to the schools and the University were soon obvious. The methods of the school visited and the fitness of the teachers for their work were made known to the visitors. The oppor tunity for suggesting improvements was furnished. Interviews with schol ars were held. Frequently the visit was made the occasion for a public address on education to the citizens. Conferences were had with the school board. An opinion could be formed concerning the willingness or unwil lingness of the town to give the needed support to the school, for the mainte nance of the proper standard of school work. An impulse was given to the public to take a new interest in the school which the University thought worthy of a visit. Above all, an inti mate and friendly relation between the school and the town on the one hand and the University on the other was established. The University was also enabled to see what was possible to the High School and was guarded against the danger of asking too much of the students as the condition of admission.
*********
"Our friends in the East have al ways expressed surprise that most of the colleges and the universities in the West have for the last thirty years educated the sexes together. They fail to see that co-education in those institutions was the natural development of the plan followed in the high schools of the West. Whereas in the high schools of the East the sexes were educated separately, in the West they were, as a rule, educated together. Having thus been instructed together up to the very door of the college, it was no violent or unnatural transition for them to enter the college together. As in fact no serious objections to their joint education have presented themselves, the usage bids fair to be continued at least in the West."
*********
"In 1873, largely through the in fluence of Mr. Claudius B. Grant, at that time a Regent of the University and a member of the legislature, we persuaded the legislature to give us the proceeds of a twentieth-mill tax. This established a most useful prece dent. In later years our twentieth- mill tax was raised first to one-eighth, then to one-quarter, and then to three-eighths of a mill. This proved to be a far better plan than the voting of special appropriations for a number of objects. It spared the legislative committees and the whole Legislature the trouble of scrutinizing a large num ber of specific requests. It also en abled the University authorities to use the funds granted them more effectively and more economically. For frequently it happened that before the term of two years for which the ap propriations were made had elapsed, it became apparent that the money granted for some particular object could be more wisely devoted to some other purpose. Furthermore it is quite essential to wise administration that the authorities of a University should be able to lay plans for some years ahead; and resting on a tax bill which experience shows is not likely to be repealed, they can adopt wise policies for the future, when they might not be able to do so if they had to depend on some specific appropriations to be renewed at every session of the Legis lature.
"I had occasion to visit the Legisla ture at several sessions to make known to our Committees, and sometimes to the whole body, our needs, and several times the whole Legislature visited the University. I wish to bear witness to the courtesy with which I was always received at Lansing, and the hearty interest in the Institution which the members of the Legislature always evinced on their visits to us.
In concluding, President Angell tells of the pleasure he has received from the visits of the distinguished men and women who have come to address the University. He says: "It seems proper to give reminiscences of some of these visits."
"Matthew Arnold, in his last visit to America, accompanied by his wife and daughter, was our guest. It may be remembered that, when lecturing in the Eastern cities, he was criticized and even ridiculed for his manner of delivery. Being near-sighted, he had a reading stand as tall as he was, and to his annoyance his manner in dart ing his head close to it at each sentence was compared to a bird pecking a t his food. This fact led him, it was said, to take some lessons in elocution from a competent teacher. His ap pearance on our stage was one of the first after this instruction. He was received by our audience with great favor, and his success was so marked that he spoke to me with much satis faction of his reception.
"Miss Edith Arnold, Mr. Arnold's niece, was my guest when she came to deliver a lecture on the Religious Novel. It was an address of high literary merit. She told me that a short time before his death Mr. Glad stone had a prolonged interview with her sister, Mrs. Humphrey Ward, in which he discussed at length with the author the religious doctrines set forth in the novel 'Robert Elsmere.' As Miss Arnold is a pronounced advocate of woman suffrage and Mrs. Ward is a leader on the other side, I asked her how they got on together in their con sideration of that subject. 'Oh, 'she said,' our difference does not in the least disturb our relations. For of course my sister does not understand the subject at all.'
"Our Law students have for many years celebrated Washington's birth day by securing an address from some eminent man. The February before Mr. Cleveland's second election to the Presidency, he was the orator of the day. I invited a number of the promi nent citizens of both political parties to meet him at my house at luncheon. An immense throng from various parts of the State came to hear his address, which was very felicitous. In the evening a public reception was held by him in the city, and on the next even ing another was held in Detroit. The result was that the Democrat party in Michigan raised with much spirit the cry for his nomination to the Presi dency. And they have always boasted that the impulse thus given led to his nomination and election.
"However that may be, his visit to Ann Arbor certainly had one result of some consequence. Years after I asked him how it happened that he chose for his permanent residence Princeton rather than New York. He replied, 'When I visited Ann Arbor, you remember that you drove with me through several of the streets of your city. And when I saw so many mode st and pleasant homes, I said to myself it is in a college town with its simple life that I will try to find a home when I am through with public life. I never lost sight of that thought. Hence my decision to live in Princeton rather than in New York.'
In summing up his life work as President of the University of Michi gan, Dr. Angell says:
"In considering the relation of the University to the State, I have always had two great ends in view.
"First: I have endeavored to induce every citizen to regard himself as a stockholder in the Institution, who had a real interest in helping make it of the greatest service to his children and those of his neighbors.
"Secondly: I have sought to make all the schools and teachers in the State understand that they and the Univer sity are parts of one united system and that therefore the young pupil in the most secluded school house in the State should be encouraged to see that the path was open from his home up to and through the University.
"The prosperity and usefulness of the University are due to the fact that these objects have been in a fair de gree accomplished.
"Although some State Universities were founded before ours, owing to the fact that the University of Michi gan at an earlier date than any of the others secured a very large attendance in all three of its departments, its in fluence in the development of all the rest has been very great. No small portion of my correspondence has been devoted to explaining to other univer sities our methods and the reasons of our comparative success. I have been called to expound the principles on , which Michigan has preceded in building up its University to most of the States, which have established their universities.
"Far be it from me to claim undue credit for the success of the Institution. Rather do I desire to speak of it with gratitude that I have been permitted to be so long associated with it in its days of prosperity. It has been a singular good fortune to be allowed to work with so many excellent men in the Board of Regents and in the Faculties and to come in touch with so many students who have gone forth to careers of usefulness in all parts of the world.
"The life of the President of a col lege or university is often spoken of as a hard and trying life. A laborious life with its anxieties it is. But I have found it a happy life. The satisfac tions it has brought to me are quite beyond my deserts. The recognition of the value of my services that has come to me in these recent days from Regents, colleagues, graduates, and undergraduates humbles me while it gratifies me.
"And one acknowledgment I desire above all to make. If I have had any success in my career, especially in the administration of the two universities, it has been largely due to the social tact and wise and untiring co-operation of my dear wife.
Perfectly unaffected and simple as these Reminiscences are, those who read will feel that in their sincerity lies a charm which those who know him have always associated with the author's personality.
President Angell’s Reminiscenes
(Reminiscences of James Burrill Angell,
Longmans, Green & Co., London, Bombay,
and Calcutta. Illustrated with photogravure
portrait, 1911. Pp. viii + 258.)